GO:0006477 protein sulfation: Post-Translational Modification, Genes, Functions and Research Methods
Research-grade guide for scientists and biopharma professionals
Key Takeaways
• GO:0006477 protein sulfation is the enzymatic addition of a sulfate group as an ester to a protein amino acid, most commonly to tyrosine residues.
• Tyrosine O-sulfation is a Golgi-localized post-translational modification that modulates extracellular protein-protein interactions and is catalyzed by tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases.
• Protein sulfation influences chemokine binding, viral entry, hemostasis, and inflammation by creating or disrupting docking sites on secreted and membrane proteins.
• Dysregulated sulfation pathways are implicated in protein aggregation diseases and cancer, making sulfotransferases and their substrates attractive research targets.
• Key experimental approaches include metabolic labeling with radioactive sulfate, anti-sulfotyrosine immunoblotting, mass spectrometry, and site-directed mutagenesis of sulfation motifs.
• CRISPR-based knockout, point-mutation, and knock-in models enable causal dissection of individual sulfation events in cell and animal systems.
Description
Protein sulfation (GO:0006477) is a post-translational modification in which a sulfate group is covalently attached as an ester to an amino acid side chain of a protein. The most extensively studied form is tyrosine O-sulfation, which occurs in the trans-Golgi network and is catalyzed by tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases (TPSTs) using 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate (PAPS) as the sulfate donor. This modification is distinct from glycosaminoglycan sulfation and from sulfation of small molecules, although sulfated glycans can also influence protein behavior in aggregation diseases. Because sulfation adds negative charge and bulk to solvent-exposed regions, it can modulate protein-protein interactions, ligand-receptor binding, and proteolytic susceptibility. For researchers, GO:0006477 matters because it sits at the interface of extracellular signaling, host-pathogen interactions, and protein quality control. Tyrosine-sulfated proteins include chemokine receptors, coagulation factors, and viral envelope proteins, where the modification can act as a molecular switch for binding events. The modification is also relevant to biotechnology and biotherapeutics, since recombinant proteins produced in different host cells may carry distinct sulfation patterns that affect potency and pharmacokinetics. Understanding which proteins are sulfated, where the modification occurs, and how it is regulated requires integrating biochemical, proteomic, and genetic approaches. This article summarizes the ontology definition, the molecular and cellular mechanisms of protein sulfation, the genes and enzymes involved, disease connections, and the experimental models, including CRISPR-based strategies, that are used to study this process. All statements are grounded in the verified literature cited by number.
protein sulfation At A Glance
| GO ID | GO:0006477 |
|---|---|
| GO term | protein sulfation |
| Ontology | biological_process |
| Synonym | protein amino acid sulfation; protein amino acid sulphation |
| Definition | The addition of a sulfate group as an ester to a protein amino acid. |
| Major function | Covalent attachment of sulfate to protein amino acids, most commonly tyrosine, to modulate protein interactions and stability. |
| Subcellular location | Primarily the trans-Golgi network for tyrosine O-sulfation. |
| Sulfate donor | 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate (PAPS). |
| Representative enzymes | Tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases TPST1 and TPST2. |
| Reverse reaction | Sulfate esters on proteins can be hydrolyzed by sulfatases, though specific protein tyrosine sulfatases remain less characterized. |
What Is GO:0006477?
According to the Gene Ontology, GO:0006477 protein sulfation is defined as the addition of a sulfate group as an ester to a protein amino acid. In practice, this means that a sulfate moiety is enzymatically transferred from a donor molecule to a hydroxyl-containing amino acid side chain, forming a covalent sulfate ester bond on the protein backbone. The term encompasses sulfation of any protein amino acid, with tyrosine O-sulfation being the best-characterized example in metazoans. The modification is a biological process rather than a molecular function or cellular component, and it is often studied together with the enzymes and donor pathways that supply sulfate groups.
Why Is protein sulfation Important in Cell Biology?
Protein sulfation is important because it is a major post-translational mechanism for tuning extracellular protein-protein interactions without changing protein abundance. By adding a negatively charged sulfate ester to tyrosine or other residues, cells can create high-affinity binding sites for chemokines, growth factors, and viral ligands, thereby influencing inflammation, hemostasis, and infection. The modification also affects protein aggregation and clearance, linking sulfation pathways to neurodegenerative and systemic amyloid diseases. In biotechnology, the sulfation state of therapeutic proteins can affect receptor binding and half-life, so understanding and controlling this modification is directly relevant to drug development.
• Modulates chemokine and cytokine binding to receptors, affecting immune cell recruitment and inflammation.
• Influences viral entry by creating sulfated docking sites on host receptors or viral proteins.
• Regulates hemostasis through sulfation of coagulation factors and inhibitors.
• Contributes to protein aggregation and amyloid deposition in disease contexts.
• Affects the binding properties of plant peptide hormones, showing evolutionary conservation of sulfation logic.
• Provides a mechanism for fine-tuning extracellular signaling without transcriptional changes.
• Creates opportunities for therapeutic intervention by targeting sulfotransferases or sulfation sites.
• Serves as a quality attribute for recombinant biotherapeutics, where sulfation heterogeneity can impact efficacy.
• Links to glycosaminoglycan biology, since sulfated glycans can co-regulate protein aggregation and binding.
• Enables functional proteomics studies of the sulfoproteome using enrichment and mass spectrometry.
What Happens During protein sulfation?
Sulfate donor synthesis and activation
In simple terms: The cell first makes an activated sulfate carrier that can donate sulfate groups to proteins.
Protein sulfation depends on the availability of 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate (PAPS), the universal sulfate donor for sulfotransferase reactions. PAPS is synthesized in the cytosol and transported into the Golgi lumen, where tyrosine O-sulfation occurs. The sulfate group in PAPS is chemically activated, allowing transfer to a hydroxyl group on a protein substrate. Because PAPS levels reflect dietary sulfate and cellular sulfur metabolism, the rate of protein sulfation can be indirectly influenced by nutrient status and by the expression of PAPS synthesis enzymes.
Recognition of target proteins by tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases
In simple terms: Enzymes in the Golgi recognize specific protein sequences and prepare to attach sulfate.
Tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases TPST1 and TPST2 are type II transmembrane enzymes resident in the trans-Golgi network. They recognize substrate proteins that present tyrosine residues in acidic sequence contexts, often within surface-exposed loops or N-terminal regions. The enzymes bind both the protein substrate and PAPS, positioning the tyrosine hydroxyl for nucleophilic attack. Substrate recognition is not strictly sequence-specific but is influenced by local charge, accessibility, and folding, which explains why only a subset of tyrosines in a given protein become sulfated.
Catalytic transfer of sulfate to tyrosine
In simple terms: The enzyme transfers the sulfate group from PAPS onto the protein, forming a stable sulfate ester.
During catalysis, the sulfotransferase transfers the sulfate group from PAPS to the hydroxyl oxygen of a tyrosine residue, forming a tyrosine O-sulfate ester and releasing 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphate (PAP). This reaction occurs in the lumen of the trans-Golgi network, so proteins destined for secretion or the plasma membrane are the primary substrates. The resulting sulfate ester is stable under physiological conditions but can be removed by sulfatases, providing a potential reversal mechanism. The modification adds negative charge and steric bulk, which can alter protein conformation and interaction surfaces.
Functional consequences for protein interactions
In simple terms: Once sulfate is attached, the protein can bind partners more strongly or in a different way.
Tyrosine sulfation frequently acts as a gain-of-function modification for protein-protein interactions. For example, sulfated tyrosines on chemokine receptors and on viral proteins can enhance binding to chemokines such as RANTES, influencing immune cell recruitment and viral pathogenesis. In hemostasis, sulfation of coagulation factors and inhibitors modulates their activity and clearance. The modification can also affect proteolytic processing and trafficking, because the added negative charge changes local electrostatics. These effects are context-dependent: the same sulfation event can promote one interaction while disrupting another.
Cross-talk with glycosaminoglycan sulfation
In simple terms: Protein sulfation does not happen in isolation; sulfated sugars on proteoglycans can influence the same biological processes.
Although GO:0006477 specifically refers to sulfation of protein amino acids, sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) are chemically related and can modulate overlapping biology. For instance, 3-O-sulfation of heparan sulfate affects protein binding and lyase degradation, and sulfated GAGs accumulate in protein aggregation diseases. Researchers studying protein sulfation should therefore consider the extracellular matrix context, because GAG chains on proteoglycans can compete with or complement sulfated protein surfaces in binding events.
Turnover and regulation of sulfated proteins
In simple terms: Sulfated proteins can be recycled or degraded, and the amount of sulfation can change with cell state.
The steady-state level of protein sulfation reflects the balance between TPST-mediated addition and removal or degradation of the modified protein. While dedicated protein tyrosine sulfatases are less well characterized than the transferases, sulfate esters can be hydrolyzed, and sulfated proteins are subject to normal secretory pathway turnover. Cellular conditions such as Golgi pH, PAPS availability, and TPST expression levels can shift sulfation patterns. In plants, sulfated peptide hormones provide a striking example of how sulfation status is developmentally and environmentally regulated.
Key Genes Involved in GO:0006477 protein sulfation
The following genes and proteins are central to the study of protein sulfation, encompassing the enzymes that catalyze the modification, the donor pathway, and well-characterized substrates.
| Gene | Major Role | Research Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| TPST1 | Tyrosylprotein sulfotransferase 1; catalyzes tyrosine O-sulfation in the Golgi | Core enzyme for studying substrate specificity and sulfation-dependent interactions |
| TPST2 | Tyrosylprotein sulfotransferase 2; catalyzes tyrosine O-sulfation | Paralog with overlapping and distinct substrate preferences; knockout models reveal redundancy |
| PAPSS1 | 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate synthase 1; produces PAPS | Limiting factor for sulfate donor supply; modulates global sulfation capacity |
| PAPSS2 | 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate synthase 2; produces PAPS | Tissue-specific PAPS synthesis; links sulfur metabolism to sulfation |
| CCR5 | Chemokine receptor; tyrosine sulfation enhances chemokine binding | Model substrate for studying sulfation-dependent HIV entry and inflammation |
| CXCR4 | Chemokine receptor; sulfated tyrosines contribute to ligand binding | Target for sulfation-site mutagenesis and binding assays |
| PSGL-1 | P-selectin glycoprotein ligand-1; sulfated tyrosines mediate selectin binding | Classic example of sulfation controlling cell adhesion |
| FVIII | Coagulation factor VIII; tyrosine sulfation affects activity | Clinically relevant substrate for sulfation in hemostasis |
| UL22A | Human cytomegalovirus protein; sulfation enhances RANTES binding | Viral model for sulfation-dependent chemokine sequestration |
| RANTES | Chemokine ligand whose binding is modulated by sulfated proteins | Readout for sulfation-dependent protein-protein interactions |
| GAG sulfotransferases | Enzymes that sulfate glycosaminoglycans | Context for cross-talk between protein and glycan sulfation |
| Sulfatases | Enzymes that remove sulfate esters | Potential reversal mechanism for protein sulfation |
| PSK | Plant peptide hormone requiring sulfation for activity | Evolutionary conservation of sulfation in signaling |
| PSY1 | Plant peptide hormone with sulfated tyrosine | Model for plant sulfation and receptor binding |
| TPST (plant) | Plant tyrosylprotein sulfotransferase | Genetic tool for studying sulfation in development |
| Aggregation-prone proteins | Proteins whose aggregation is influenced by sulfated glycans | Link between sulfation biology and protein aggregation diseases |
How Is protein sulfation Regulated?
Protein sulfation is regulated at multiple levels. The availability of the sulfate donor PAPS, determined by PAPSS1 and PAPSS2 expression and sulfur metabolism, sets the ceiling for sulfation capacity. TPST1 and TPST2 expression levels and their localization in the trans-Golgi network control which proteins encounter the enzymes. Substrate accessibility, governed by protein folding and trafficking, determines which tyrosine residues are modified. In plants, sulfated peptide hormone signaling is developmentally regulated, indicating that sulfation can be under organism-level control. Additionally, extracellular factors such as glycosaminoglycan sulfation can modulate the functional consequences of protein sulfation, creating a layered regulatory network.
protein sulfation and Human Disease
| Gene | Disease / Biology | Potential Experimental Model |
|---|---|---|
| TPST1/TPST2 | Inflammation and immune cell recruitment | Knockout cell lines and mouse models to assess chemokine binding |
| CCR5 | HIV entry and inflammatory disease | Point mutation of sulfation sites followed by viral entry assays |
| UL22A | Cytomegalovirus immune evasion | Knock-in of sulfated UL22A variants in viral or cellular systems |
| Aggregation-prone proteins | Amyloidosis and neurodegeneration | Overexpression models with sulfated glycan co-treatment |
| PSK/PSY1 | Plant growth and development | Plant knockout and knock-in lines for sulfation-site analysis |
Protein sulfation in inflammation and immune regulation
Tyrosine sulfation of chemokine receptors and adhesion molecules is a key determinant of leukocyte recruitment and inflammatory responses. Sulfated tyrosines on receptors such as CCR5 and CXCR4 enhance binding to chemokines, and sulfation of PSGL-1 is required for selectin-mediated adhesion. Viral proteins can exploit this system; the human cytomegalovirus protein UL22A is sulfated and thereby binds RANTES more effectively, potentially modulating host immune responses. These examples position protein sulfation as a therapeutic node in inflammatory and infectious diseases.
Sulfation and protein aggregation diseases
Sulfated glycosaminoglycans are consistently found in amyloid deposits and other protein aggregation diseases, where they can accelerate fibril formation and stabilize aggregates. Although GO:0006477 specifically covers protein amino acid sulfation, the interplay between sulfated glycans and aggregation-prone proteins suggests that sulfation pathways broadly influence proteostasis. Researchers studying neurodegenerative and systemic amyloidoses should consider both protein sulfation and glycan sulfation as contributing factors.
Sulfation in hemostasis and thrombosis
Several coagulation factors and their regulators undergo tyrosine sulfation, which can affect their activity, cofactor binding, and clearance. Because hemostasis depends on precise protein-protein interactions in the bloodstream, changes in sulfation status may alter clotting dynamics. This makes sulfation enzymes and substrate sites potential modifiers in bleeding and thrombotic disorders, although the clinical significance of individual sulfation events requires further study.
Sulfation in plant development and biotechnology
In plants, sulfated peptide hormones such as PSK and PSY1 regulate growth and development, and their activity depends on tyrosine sulfation. This conservation highlights the fundamental importance of sulfation in cell-cell communication. For biotechnology, understanding plant sulfation pathways can inform crop engineering and the production of sulfated peptides, while also providing a simpler genetic system to study sulfation mechanisms.
From protein sulfation-Related Genes to Experimental Models
| Research Question | Suitable Model |
|---|---|
| Does loss of TPST1/TPST2 abolish tyrosine sulfation of a target protein? | CRISPR knockout of TPST1 and/or TPST2 in cultured cells |
| Which tyrosine residues are sulfated in a candidate protein? | Point mutation of individual tyrosines to phenylalanine followed by sulfation assays |
| Can a sulfation-mimetic mutation restore binding? | Knock-in of a tyrosine-to-glutamate or sulfate-mimetic variant |
| How does sulfation affect protein-protein interactions in vivo? | Tagged knock-in of the substrate protein and interaction proteomics |
| What is the effect of increased sulfation capacity? | Overexpression of TPST1/TPST2 or PAPSS enzymes |
| Is a sulfation event conserved in plants? | Plant knockout and knock-in lines of TPST or peptide hormones |
How to Study the protein sulfation Process
| Method | What It Measures | Typical Application |
|---|---|---|
| Metabolic [35S]-sulfate labeling | Incorporation of radioactive sulfate into proteins | Confirming protein sulfation in cells |
| Anti-sulfotyrosine immunoblot | Relative levels of sulfated tyrosine on proteins | Comparing sulfation between wild-type and knockout cells |
| Anti-sulfotyrosine immunoprecipitation | Enrichment of sulfated proteins | Sulfoproteome profiling prior to mass spectrometry |
| LC-MS/MS | Site-specific identification of sulfated peptides | Mapping sulfation sites on candidate proteins |
| Surface plasmon resonance | Binding affinity between sulfated protein and partner | Testing functional impact of sulfation sites |
| Cell adhesion assay | Adhesion dependent on sulfated ligands | Studying PSGL-1 and selectin interactions |
| Site-directed mutagenesis | Effect of removing individual sulfation sites | Dissecting which tyrosines are functionally important |
| CRISPR knockout | Loss of sulfotransferase or substrate function | Causal testing of sulfation in a biological process |
Metabolic labeling with radioactive sulfate
Cells can be incubated with [35S]-sulfate to metabolically label newly synthesized sulfated proteins. After immunoprecipitation of the protein of interest, radioactivity incorporation is measured by autoradiography or scintillation counting. This method provides direct evidence of sulfation but requires careful controls to distinguish protein sulfation from glycosaminoglycan sulfation. It is particularly useful for confirming that a candidate protein carries sulfate esters.
Anti-sulfotyrosine immunoblotting and immunoprecipitation
Antibodies specific for sulfotyrosine can be used to detect sulfated proteins on immunoblots or to enrich sulfated proteins from lysates. These reagents enable relative quantification of sulfation across conditions and can be combined with gene knockout to validate specificity. Because anti-sulfotyrosine antibodies may cross-react with other sulfated molecules, orthogonal validation by mass spectrometry is recommended.
Mass spectrometry-based sulfoproteomics
Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) can identify sulfated peptides and localize the modified residue. Enrichment strategies, such as anti-sulfotyrosine immunoprecipitation or chemical tagging, improve coverage of the sulfoproteome. Mass spectrometry is the most definitive method for site-specific assignment of sulfate esters, although the labile nature of sulfation requires optimized fragmentation conditions.
Functional binding assays
Once a sulfation site is identified, its functional role can be tested using binding assays such as surface plasmon resonance, isothermal titration calorimetry, or cell-based adhesion assays. Comparing wild-type and sulfation-deficient mutant proteins reveals whether sulfation enhances or inhibits a given interaction. These assays are essential for linking the modification to biological outcomes such as chemokine binding or viral entry.
How CRISPR Can Be Used to Study GO:0006477 protein sulfation
Knockout
CRISPR knockout of TPST1, TPST2, or PAPSS genes eliminates or reduces protein sulfation capacity, allowing researchers to test which biological processes depend on this modification. Knockout cell lines can be compared with parental cells using anti-sulfotyrosine immunoblotting or metabolic labeling to confirm loss of sulfation. Organism-level knockouts can reveal developmental or immune phenotypes, although redundancy between TPST1 and TPST2 may require double knockouts.
Point Mutation
Point mutation of individual tyrosine codons to phenylalanine in a candidate substrate prevents sulfation at that site without altering the rest of the protein. This approach is ideal for dissecting the contribution of specific sulfation events to binding, signaling, or trafficking. CRISPR-based base editing or homology-directed repair can introduce these mutations at endogenous loci, preserving physiological expression levels.
Knock-in
Knock-in strategies can add epitope tags to sulfated proteins for enrichment and detection, or introduce sulfation-mimetic mutations such as tyrosine-to-glutamate to test gain-of-function. Tagged knock-in lines enable immunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry from physiologically relevant samples. Knock-in of viral or bacterial effectors that exploit sulfation can model host-pathogen interactions.
Overexpression
Overexpression of TPST1, TPST2, or PAPSS enzymes increases cellular sulfation capacity and can enhance sulfation of co-expressed substrates. This is useful for producing sulfated recombinant proteins for structural or binding studies. Overexpression of a substrate protein can also reveal whether sulfation becomes limiting under high expression conditions, informing bioprocess optimization.
How EDITGENE Supports protein sulfation Research
Researchers studying protein sulfation-related genes often need to determine whether a candidate gene is causally involved in sulfation-dependent biology, which requires precise genetic models that isolate the modification from confounding effects. EDITGENE provides CRISPR-based cell model services that enable knockout, point mutation, knock-in, and overexpression of sulfation pathway components and substrate proteins, supported by library screening and bioinformatics for pathway discovery.
Contact EDITGENE today to design your custom CRISPR model for protein sulfation research.
Frequently Asked Questions About protein sulfation
What is protein sulfation (GO:0006477)?
Protein sulfation is the addition of a sulfate group as an ester to a protein amino acid, most commonly tyrosine, and is catalyzed by sulfotransferases such as TPST1 and TPST2 in the Golgi.
What genes are involved in protein sulfation?
Key genes include TPST1, TPST2, PAPSS1, and PAPSS2, which encode the enzymes that catalyze sulfation and synthesize the sulfate donor PAPS.
Where does protein sulfation occur in the cell?
Tyrosine O-sulfation occurs primarily in the trans-Golgi network, where tyrosylprotein sulfotransferases modify proteins destined for secretion or the plasma membrane.
What is the difference between protein sulfation and glycosaminoglycan sulfation?
Protein sulfation (GO:0006477) modifies amino acid side chains, whereas glycosaminoglycan sulfation modifies sugar chains on proteoglycans; both can influence protein interactions but are distinct biochemical processes.
How is protein sulfation detected in the laboratory?
Common methods include metabolic labeling with radioactive sulfate, anti-sulfotyrosine immunoblotting, immunoprecipitation, and mass spectrometry for site-specific mapping.
Why is tyrosine sulfation important for protein-protein interactions?
Sulfated tyrosines add negative charge and bulk that can create or strengthen binding sites for chemokines, selectins, and viral proteins, thereby modulating signaling and adhesion.
Can protein sulfation be reversed?
Sulfate esters can be hydrolyzed by sulfatases, although the specific enzymes that remove sulfate from protein tyrosines are less well characterized than the transferases.
What diseases are associated with altered protein sulfation?
Altered sulfation has been linked to inflammatory diseases, viral infections, hemostatic disorders, and protein aggregation diseases, based on studies of chemokine receptors, viral proteins, and sulfated glycans.
How can CRISPR be used to study protein sulfation?
CRISPR knockout of TPST1/TPST2 or PAPSS genes eliminates sulfation capacity, while point mutations of tyrosine codons prevent sulfation at specific sites, enabling causal tests of sulfation function.
Is protein sulfation conserved in plants?
Yes, plants use tyrosine-sulfated peptide hormones such as PSK and PSY1 for growth and development, indicating evolutionary conservation of sulfation-based signaling.
Conclusion
Protein sulfation (GO:0006477) is a biologically significant post-translational modification that shapes extracellular protein interactions, immune responses, hemostasis, and host-pathogen encounters. Its study requires a combination of biochemical detection methods, functional binding assays, and genetic models that can isolate individual sulfation events. CRISPR-based knockout, point-mutation, knock-in, and overexpression models provide the precision needed to move from correlation to causation in sulfation research. As the sulfoproteome expands through improved mass spectrometry and enrichment techniques, the list of sulfation-dependent processes will continue to grow, offering new opportunities for therapeutic intervention and biotechnology applications. Researchers can accelerate this progress by pairing robust cell models with pathway-level screening and bioinformatics analysis.
References
- 1. Niehrs C et al.. 1994. Protein tyrosine sulfation, 1993--an update.. Chem Biol Interact 92(1-3):257-71 PMID: 8033259
- 2. Kehoe JW et al.. 2000. Tyrosine sulfation: a modulator of extracellular protein-protein interactions.. Chem Biol 7(3):R57-61 PMID: 10712936
- 3. Corbeil D et al.. 2005. Tyrosine O-sulfation.. Curr Protoc Protein Sci Chapter 14:14.7.1-14.7.14 PMID: 18429275
- 4. Chopra P et al.. 2021. The 3-O-sulfation of heparan sulfate modulates protein binding and lyase degradation.. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 118(3) PMID: 33441484
- 5. Nishitsuji K et al.. 2017. Sulfated glycosaminoglycans in protein aggregation diseases.. Glycoconj J 34(4):453-466 PMID: 28401373
- 6. Wang X et al.. 2017. Sulfation of the Human Cytomegalovirus Protein UL22A Enhances Binding to the Chemokine RANTES.. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 56(29):8490-8494 PMID: 28488292
- 7. Bundgaard JR et al.. 2008. Analysis of tyrosine-O-sulfation.. Methods Mol Biol 446:47-66 PMID: 18373249
- 8. Kaufmann C et al.. 2019. Sulfated plant peptide hormones.. J Exp Bot 70(16):4267-4277 PMID: 31231771